Content note: 1884 cartoon with a Chinese-idol caricature. This object is shown as it was published. Why

A little private mutual admiration scheme, - Joss Ben, 1884 US cartoon: Puck cover by Frederick Burr Opper, 27 August 1884

A little private mutual admiration scheme, - Joss Ben and his only priest, Sun-Sun

Puck cover by Frederick Burr Opper, 27 August 1884: Benjamin F. Butler as a seated Chinese idol ('A Goodman Weighing 250 lbs.') while Charles A. Dana of the New York Sun, as his only priest, burns papers headed 'Butler's praises' and 'Butler's statesmanship'. A clipping at right quotes the New York Sun of 17 September 1878 saying Butler had ceased to be a Democrat.

Frederick Burr Opper drew this Puck cover of 27 August 1884. Benjamin F. Butler sits as a Chinese idol ('A Goodman Weighing 250 lbs.') while Charles A. Dana of the New York Sun, as his only priest, burns papers headed 'Butler's praises' and 'Butler's statesmanship'. A clipping quotes the Sun of 17 September 1878 saying Butler had ceased to be a Democrat. Both men are drawn in Chinese costume, and Chinese people are drawn in period caricature. Name-calling mocks the Sun's support of Butler as a private scheme.

Propaganda techniques used in this cartoon

Date
August 27, 1884
Period
Pre-1914
Made by
Puck (Keppler & Schwarzmann, New York); artist Frederick Burr Opper

Full record

Region, Country, Medium, Issuer type, Regime, Leader, Audience, Purpose, Theme, Event, Source, Rights
Region
North America
Medium
Cartoon
Issuer type
Media
Regime
Arthur Administration
Leader
Chester A. Arthur
Audience
Domestic public
Purpose
Demonize
Theme
Elections and party politics
Event
1884 US Election
Source
Identified Openly sourced: the speaker is who they say they are
Source
Library of Congress, retrieved October 2, 2026
Rights
Public domain by age (published 1884); LOC rights advisory: No known restrictions on publication
Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division, Washington, D.C. 20540 USA