"The Mulligan guard lies, but - surrenders"
Puck centerfold by Joseph Keppler, 19 November 1884: an explosion at the 'Claim Agency, formerly Republican Head Quarters' flattens Republican kiosks and leaves Blaine, Logan, Whitelaw Reid, Butler, Dana, Burchard (labelled 'R.R.R.') and others on the ground holding 'We still claim' papers, while Cleveland and a flag-bearing Independent look on from horseback at upper left. Caption: 'The Mulligan guard lies, but - surrenders.'
A Puck centerfold by Joseph Keppler, published in New York on 19 November 1884, after the vote while New York's result was still contested. An explosion at the 'Claim Agency, formerly Republican Head Quarters' flattens kiosks and leaves Blaine, Logan, Whitelaw Reid, Butler, Dana and others on the ground holding 'We still claim' papers, while Cleveland looks on from horseback. The caption says the Mulligan guard lies but surrenders. 'Mulligan Guard' is name-calling, and showing the winners triumphant is bandwagon.
Propaganda techniques used in this cartoon
- Date
- November 19, 1884
- Period
- Pre-1914
- Made by
- Puck (Keppler & Schwarzmann, New York); artist Joseph Keppler
Full record
Region, Country, Medium, Issuer type, Regime, Leader, Audience, Purpose, Theme, Event, Source, Rights
- Region
- North America
- Country
- United States
- Medium
- Cartoon
- Issuer type
- Media
- Regime
- Arthur Administration
- Leader
- Chester A. Arthur
- Audience
- Domestic public
- Purpose
- Demonize
- Theme
- Elections and party politics
- Event
- 1884 US Election
- Source
- Identified Openly sourced: the speaker is who they say they are
- Source
- Library of Congress, retrieved October 2, 2026
- Rights
- Public domain by age (published 1884); LOC rights advisory: No known restrictions on publication
Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division, Washington, D.C. 20540 USA







